SPP Research Seminar Series: The Effects of Immigration Enforcement on Traffic Stops: Changing Driver or Police Behavior?

Abstract: This research asks whether jail-based immigration enforcement leads to the profiling of Hispanics by municipal police. van Tiem leverages a natural experiment to examine the effects of 287(g) jail partnerships on traffic stops and arrests by municipal police in North Carolina in the late 2000s. She finds that stops of Hispanic drivers fell in the wake of 287(g) agreements and show that this fall was driven by changes in Hispanic road use. While police and driver behavior cannot unambiguously disentangle, there is no evidence that municipal police officers increased pretextual stops and arrests of Hispanic drivers. Policy Implications: While there is existing evidence of racial profiling under 287(g) agreements by sheriff’s deputies, this behavior does not appear to have extended to nonsignatory municipal police agencies. Despite this, the signing of 287(g) agreements appears to have prompted Hispanic outmigration and changes in driving behavior, adding to a growing body of evidence on the ripple effects of local-federal immigration enforcement partnerships in Hispanic communities. This serves as a reminder that changes in demographic composition of the immigrant population may mediate the effects of immigration enforcement efforts on other outcomes.